2008
Hot and Sour Soup with Bread Bowl
Filed Under (Photography, Recipes, Royal Foodie Joust, asian, bread, dinners, food, hot and sour, mushrooms, soup, whole wheat ginger lemon) by petermarcus on 21-08-2008
This is my entry for this month’s Royal Foodie Joust from Jenn, the Leftover Queen.
Kittie won last month (congratulations Kittie) and her choices for this month’s joust were:
*Whole Grain
*Ginger
*Citrus
I made a crystallized ginger and lemon rind wheat bread with bulgar (whole wheat), and a hot and sour soup with ginger, lemon juice, garnished with popcorn (another whole grain). I formed the bread into a bowl and used it to hold the soup.

I got the inspiration for both recipes from Bon Appétit magazine, by way of Epicurious, but I adapted them a bit and then threw them together. Still, originals are here: Bread and Soup.
The bread, of course, takes a while to make, so I started with that:
1 1/2 cups buttermilk, warmed to 105-ish degrees:


While the milk was warming, I gathered 1/4 cup crystallized ginger, minced:


I used my breadmaker to kneed and rise the dough, because I’m not a big baker and these machines are marvels of breadkneeding technology. So, I poured the milk into the breadmaker along with 1/2 stick butter, warmed to room temperature, 3 tablespoons sugar, and a packet of yeast. This would proof for 8-10 minutes, while I gathered the other ingredients.





While it was proofing, I zested and minced 1 tsp lemon rind. I also took 3 tablespoons of whole wheat, put it in a bag, then smashed it up a bit with the flat part of my meat mallet (to crack it up a bit).





I also measured 3/4 cup whole wheat flour, and 3 cups unbleached white flour.


The yeast had frothed up, so I added in the flour, the rind and ginger, and the whole wheat. I set the breadmachine to “Dough Only” and kicked it on.


1 1/2 hours later, I had a nice, risen dough. It smelled really, good, too! I punched it down, cut it into four pieces, and formed it into round mounds. 30 minutes more under a towel to rise a bit more, and they were ready for the oven. 375F, for 30-40 minutes (until brown and hollow-sounding).







I let the bread cool down, then sliced off the top and pulled out the soft center. I’ve heard of some cooks putting the hollowed bread back into the oven to toast the insides, but the crust seemed pretty watertight, so I left it the way it was.
Meanwhile, I started the soup. I put 2 cups of chicken stock into a bowl, and added 1oz of dried shiitake mushrooms


These would soak for about 10 minutes. Meanwhile, I sliced and minced some Asian trinity — 2 scallions (green only), 2 cloves garlic, and 1 tablespoon of ginger root.




I squeeze the juice out of the mushrooms, and sliced them thinly.


I also seeded and diced 2 red jalapenos.

In a hot pan, I added a bit of olive oil and sauteed the Asian trinity. Once the smell made the kitchen wonderful, I added the jalapeno, sauteed for another minute, then added the mushroom/chicken broth.




I brought the soup to a light simmer, and added the shiitake. I cut about 6oz firm tofu into cubes, and added them to the soup, then added about 1 tablespoon sesame oil, and 1 tablespoon soy sauce.





In a measuring cup, I added 2 tablespoons rice vinegar (plain, not seasoned), and the juice of one lemon. To this, I added 1 tablespoon corn starch and mixed to a slurry.




Popcorn is actually a whole grain, and even though I had whole wheat in the bread, I wanted a whole grain with the soup. Popcorn is a great soup garnish — it sucks up the liquid and makes a great taste.


One minute before serving, heat up the soup to a little more aggressive simmer, pour in the cornstarch slurry, and stir for 60 seconds or so until the soup thickens.
Plating: pour soup in bread bowl, reserve the cap (makes a great dunking tool, like the popcorn), and garnish with popcorn.

Deconstruction: This was very tasty. I’m really not a baker, the exact proportions for a good dough will spin my head a bit. This was an easy recipe, though, even with the complexity of the ginger and rind and whole wheat. The breadmaker helped enormously — I’ve kneeded dough by hand before, and the little machine did a much better job than I ever would, and I didn’t end up coated in flour.
The soup was almost a stew, I could probably have used another cup of chicken stock, except it was really good as a stew. Really meaty and hearty with the tofu and shiitake. The lemon added a great tang with the rice vinegar, too. I was tasting the soup as I was cooking it, and it was getting better and better, and as soon as I added the acid, it was like a light-bulb went off — this is great! This meal took a while, but it’s definitely one to make again.







Oh my– hot & sour soup and your hands– two of my favorite things! Seriously though– beautiful food beautifully shot. I particularly liked the flour photos, the red jalapenos and squeezing the mushrooms.
Nice entry you guys!
I love the creativity that comes out of tropical storms! 
i love that soup. def making it soon.
Very unusual combination, but it sounds like the two will blend. Fusion cooking for the win!
What a wonderful series of really great and original ideas. Crystallized ginger in soup, soup served in bread, popcorn garnish. And it all seems like it would work really well. Bravo!
my god - this post is amazing. truly… the baking, the recipe - the photos!!! day-um. i’m impressed.
except this
you do all that amazing work and then use microwaved popcorn??? what are you thinking??? you needed to get one more pot dirty…. and pop your corn with bacon grease. it is wonderful. and buy the corn from rancho gordo!!!
ok - i’m done with my popcorn rant.
you deserve to win this joust…
Mary — Hi! Thanks! Christey told me she uploaded the photos and when I looked in the directory, I said: “51? There are 51 photos here?” There were a lot of different parts to this recipe
Jenn — Yeah, all of us Florida bloggers should have scheduled a post-a-thon
tm1nor — It’s one of my favorite soups, too, and I’d never made it before. But this was tasty!
Tom — Crystallized ginger in the bread, regular (minced up) ginger root in the soup. But, yeah, I was trying for a flow
Claudia — Ha! I was thinking of using regular popcorn, but I actually don’t have any in the house. I had all the other ingredients, because I was planning on making it this week…but then Tropical Storm Fay hit us, and I wasn’t going to run out for unpopped popcorn during a natural disaster
That might be the coolest bowl of soup I’ve ever seen. I would never think to make something like that, the bread alone sounds fantastic. I think you’re a sure winner.
oh my. it loooks sooooo delicious. i love soups in bread and i never really tried one with a “Clear” soup pase.
just a small question, can i substitute the jalepanos for just plain red chilli?
Nick — Thanks! I used to live in Atlanta, and there were a couple deli chains that would serve soup in bread bowls, and the Atlanta airport has a Sam Adams restaurant that serves a cheddar beer soup that they garnish with popcorn, so I just kinda merged everything
Amy — Sure, the original recipe called for pepper “flakes”. I thought diced red jalapeno would look good as well as taste good, and it’s a pepper I’m really familiar with. I don’t see any problem substituting peppers as long as the heat is where you want it to be.
Thanks for all the step by step photos. I just want to drink that soup right out of the bowl (no spoon, just pour :)) and then eat the bowl. Yum!
Hot and sour soup is probably the last soup I would think to put in a bread bowl but all the great complimentary flavors in the bread make me want to try this. Great set of photos too!
Hillary — We ended up doing something very similar to that
Maggie — Yeah, it sounds weirdly cross-cultural, even for a fusion, but the citrus and ginger taste and smell of the bread made it work.
spectacular bread!!!!
So unusual, with the asian flavours in bread. I like that you’ve carried the flavours into the bowl!
Bee — Thanks!
Kittie — Hi there! Yeah, it was almost the other way around. I don’t know if I would have put hot and sour into any bread bowl, but I knew I wanted soup-in-bread, and once I decided on a bread recipe incorporating the ginger and lemon rind, I thought Asian for the soup. Definitely worked, and definitely a fun challenge this month!